Open Letter to the “Critically Thinking” Group of The 5 Doc’s
This letter is directed to The 5 Docs, the self-proclaimed “Critically Thinking” group of The 5 Docs: Dr. Sherri Tenpenny, Dr. Lee Merritt, Dr. Palevsky, Dr. Northrup, and former Dr. Carrie Madej. Specifically, I am addressing Dr. Tenpenny, Dr. Merritt, Dr. Palevsky, and Dr. Northrup.
I aim to briefly explain a complex and distressing situation that occurred in our home:
On Saturday, May 27, 2023, we engaged in a written conversation with Dr. Sherri Tenpenny via Skype chat. During this discussion, we informed her that Carrie Madej had visited our home on December 5, 2021, and injected my wife, myself, and our father, Stefan Suto, with 21 ml of food-grade hydrogen peroxide mixed with 500 ml of dextrose intravenously. Dr. Madej also nebulized Stefan with an improper formula containing 2 ml of food-grade hydrogen peroxide mixed with 0.5 ml of water, without saline. We have substantial evidence of these events, including written admissions from Carrie Madej herself.
We informed Dr. Tenpenny that our father, Stefan, particularly suffered a rapid decline following Dr. Madej’s intervention to the point where he could barely eat, drink, or speak. Despite our pleas, Dr. Madej refused to return to assess his condition, which, at the time, we did not realize was due to her improperly administered hydrogen peroxide protocol. She left our family in distress, offering only prayers and claiming to be preoccupied with her own detox regimen and video production. Instead of returning, she mailed us a box of IV supplies, including more peroxide, and recommended repeating the same formula five more times on our father and my wife, Jana.
Stefan was subsequently transferred to a licensed medical facility in Florida, where doctors continued using Dr. Madej’s protocol, adding their own ozonated saline IV and direct ozone gas. These doctors were also part of the so-called “medical freedom” community. Sadly, Stefan passed away a few days later. A forensic autopsy revealed that he died as a result of hydrogen peroxide and other treatments, which caused hemolysis by destroying his red blood cells.
Following Stefan’s death, we investigated the treatments administered by Dr. Madej and the Florida physicians, discovering that these protocols were toxic, unproven, and dangerously inappropriate for human use. Dr. Madej’s administration of 21 ml of food-grade hydrogen peroxide was a toxic overdose. She caused significant pain and suffering without ever providing a consent form or warning us of the potential dangers of her treatment.
We have filed a lawsuit against Dr. Madej for her actions, as she has refused to take responsibility. We have also reported her to the Georgia Medical Board, urging them to investigate whether her hydrogen peroxide formula complies with any accepted medical standards. Upon learning of the lawsuit, Dr. Madej voluntarily surrendered her medical license, joining a “sovereign citizen” movement, and falsely claimed that she relinquished her license due to persecution. Regrettably, many, including you, have accepted this false narrative.
Dr. Madej has shown contempt for the legal process, refusing to defend herself or appear in court proceedings. The judge found her liable for Stefan’s death, and we are now awaiting an award for punitive damages.
We retain all correspondence with Dr. Sherri Tenpenny, who expressed horror when she learned the details of Dr. Madej’s protocol, calling it a “poison.” In writing, Dr. Tenpenny stated, “Dose makes a poison,” and even suggested that Dr. Madej’s actions could be criminal. However, Dr. Tenpenny also expressed concern that if the public became aware of what occurred, her “business” or “movement” could suffer.
Days later, when my wife, Jana, requested a private conversation with Dr. Tenpenny to discuss the incident in detail, Dr. Tenpenny refused, stating she saw no reason to be involved. She has since declined further communication with us. Astonishingly, despite her knowledge of Dr. Madej’s actions, Dr. Tenpenny invited her onto her program and promoted her publicly.
Dr. Northrup, we have video evidence of an interview you conducted with Dr. Madej just two months before she visited our home. In that interview, Dr. Madej publicly disclosed that she uses food-grade hydrogen peroxide intravenously and in a nebulizer. She specifically stated her formula was 5-6 ml of 3% food-grade hydrogen peroxide mixed with 500 ml of saline. However, when she treated us, she injected 21 ml of food-grade hydrogen peroxide into a 500 ml dextrose bag—more than four times the concentration she publicly stated on your program. During the interview, you appeared to agree with and support her protocol. We would like to understand your response to what happened to us and how you view the drastic discrepancy between the protocol Dr. Madej publicly described and what she actually administered.
After Stefan’s death, we thoroughly investigated these treatments ourselves. As Israeli News Live, we have always respected the doctors in your movement, offering our platform during the COVID pandemic so your voices could be heard. Dr. Madej was a guest in our home, where we provided her with care, food, shelter, and financial support, even encouraging our audience to support her.
We now ask you—Dr. Tenpenny, Dr. Merritt, Dr. Palevsky, and Dr. Northrup—why you continue to promote and tolerate Dr. Madej among you, knowing exactly what she has done. Would any of you subject yourselves or others to an injection of 21 ml of hydrogen peroxide? What evidence do you have that this protocol is safe or appropriate?
Moreover, Dr. Madej has misled you in other matters, falsely claiming that 911 responders demanded her COVID status, social security number, and health insurance information during a plane crash. We have obtained the full 911 call recording, and it clearly shows her allegations are untrue, yet you have allowed these lies to be presented as fact on your platforms.
https://iconnectfx.com/view/2b2955a4-db51-ee11-996d-0050568299de/en
We formally request that your group contact us at Israeli News Live to have an open discussion on these matters. We are prepared to present our evidence, and we invite you to make your statements. To contact us, please email us at [email protected].
This is our first public request to the “Critically Thinking” The 5 Docs. If we do not hear from you, further public requests will follow, along with the publication of all supporting evidence on our website.
Sincerely,
Steve Ben-Nun
Israeli News Live
To Dr. Sherri Tenpenny and the rest of “The Five”,
I want ya’ll to know that your Appearance of “gathering round the wagons” to protect someone ya’ll have known as “a fellow doctor” is causing me GREAT Angst against the medical profession that I already have lost faith and trust in because of the whole “covid” nonsense!! As a very close, years long, sister in Jesus Christ to Steven and Jana, I was VERY Familiar with everything they and the INL Ministry was doing to support ya’ll, and your message. They provided the INL Platform for ya’ll to speak to people!!
I was also ACCUTELY AWARE Of what Carrie madej was doing at their home in December 2021, AND Her Refusal to return, leading Jana and Daddy to deteriorate toward death!!! I was constantly on the phone with Jana, and frankly, what Carrie Madej did, AND THEN REFUSED TO Come back and reexamine infuriates the daylights out of me!! We TRUSTED Her, AND We trusted you 5 doctors!!
Carrie Madej HAS BEEN Found complacent in Daddy’s death, and it seems to me that ya’ll have the Responsibility to do the Right thing in supporting and helping Steven and Jana in this horrible situation. I’ve heard ya’ll talk about “being Christians” over the last 4 years. Well then, prove to me that you are, and do the right thing to bring justice to this horrific wrong. Otherwise, for me anyway, ya’ll are just more “mouth horns” out to make a name for yourselves, and to hell with what is right and just. Sorry!! I’m just being my honest self.
Doctors, do the right thing. Be ethical and responsible to your medical oath, “do no harm”. You are protecting the wrong person for the wrong reasons.
To the “Christian doctors”::
The Word of eternal truth brings it to light:
Mt 7:20 Wherefore by their fruits ye shall know them.
Your fruits are displayed in the open
Repent, repent, repent before its to late…. the end is within reach,… we of all ages are the last generation on earth … a new earth created by God Almighty in a moment of time is due shortly.
To the Five Doctors,
This is an absolutely shocking situation on several levels. The most shocking part to me, is that the person who caused such heartbreak, is apparently not repentant nor taking responsibility, but professes to be a follower of the Most High God!
This person needs to do the right thing while living or she will have repercussions after her life ends. She needs to know this!
Sadly, doctors bury their mistakes, don’t they and rarely take responsibility for them.? I used to listen to and admire you doctors during the Covid hoax, but have for some time now felt you have another agenda entirely. What Dr. Madej has done to the Ben Num family is not only despicable, but criminal and she needs to be appropriately punished.
You other four are certainly complicit in this tragedy by refusing to speak out against it.
You need to pray for guidance and forgiveness for this awful situation that your silence is perpetrating.
It amazes me how these so called and touted doctors cover, protect and continue to promote a criminal. No responsibility taken and not even a word of comfort to the Ben Nun family for their loss, pain or trauma. This just cements what I’ve always thought about the medical community: profits over people.
May God expose ALL culpable parties like the noonday sun in the Name of Jesus Christ! Repent IF you are a true believer, is it not written: It is a fearful and terrifying thing to fall into the hands of the living God [incurring His judgment and wrath].
I’m am so sorry that this ever happened to you and your father. May the love of CHRIST hold, heal, surround and comfort you both!!!
I’m so disappointed to hear the response from Dr. Tenpenny. This reminds me a lot of when a preacher is revealed to actually be a pedophile. preying on the children or having an affair or embezzling church donations, and the deacon board rallies around them to protect them. They are the wolves, it’s the congregants or the patients in this case that need the protection. I’m so sorry Jana that this happened to your dad, my heart is heavy for you and I pray all the time that you and your family will receive justice.
For they loved the praise of men more than the praise of God. John 12:43
Their own reputation is more important than the truth.
For the time is come that judgment must begin at the house of God: and if it first begin at us, what shall the end be of them that obey not the gospel of God? 1 Peter 4:17
It boils down to who is being worshipped? God or mammon?
And have no fellowship with the unfruitful works of darkness, but rather reprove them. Ephesians 5:11
We must stand against evil.
In my opinion the 5 doctors, who are supporting Madej is no better. She murdered Jana father, and they dont do anything.. Why, what are they up to… Wonder if they are trying to se how far they can go, using innocent people.
So sorry Jana, so very sorry. But I believe we are close to the 2 coming of our Saivor. You will soon hugg your father again. I hope I will to with my parents..
Oh wow! I don’t even have any words…I am in shock and disbelief by this situation. I believed in these doctors and what they were saying! Are they all fakes? It’s just mind blowing and so sad and I’m so sorry for what happened to your father and Jana at the hand of dr. Madej…someone you thought was your friend and doing what was good for your father! And even stayed in your home! Just unbelievable! I am praying for you all and for your protection and healing and strength. God bless you and be with you! Stay strong!
I remember during Covid I went to a group of online doctors because my husband and myself had come down with it. I remember people saying how cheap ivermectin was a how well it worked on the virus. Well by the time we got an appointment and were to receive the RX we were better on our own. Because of the cost of the ivermectin and the cost of our online doctor’s appointments we could not afford to fill the prescriptions. For 2 patients and 2 prescriptions it was in the area of $1000.00. These doctors were not helping their patients they were only helping their bank accounts! Sorry to hear of your tragedy! Praying for peace for you and your family.
Dr. Madej and the Florida doctors should all be charged and prosecuted for 1st degree murder and be convicted and punished with a life sentence in prison with no parole. All the doctors promoting Dr. Madej who are aware of her crime should be boycotted. All doctors using unsafe medical treatments should have their license revoked and be prosecuted if their medical treatments have caused harm to their patients. Unrepentant murderers and their supporters will face the eternal damnnation of hell. Carrie Madej wrote on her legal document that her God is the God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob. Well that God is Moloch/Baal/Lucifer/Yaldabaoth. Satan has many names.
I’m sorry for the suffering of the Ben Nun family and I hope you receive justice.
Just a head’s up: there’s no apostrophe in 5 Docs. It’s purely plural, not possessive.
Keep up the good work.
TY
thank you got it all corrected
My condolences. I wondered why Carrie Madej disappeared online. Now this explains why. Thank you for exposing this. Godspeed.
I am so sorry, Jana, Steven, and family for your loss. These individuals – particularly Madej – should be in jail.
So very sad and so disgustingly disappointing. Carrie actually does have a website: Practicing the truth in health. Seriously. I am on her email but I won’t be following her anymore or the rest of the 5 docs. Thanks for sharing this.
I am a board certified MD and I cannot believe what Carrie Madej has done as someone trained in medicine. I know of no one that would have treated any patient with the drug cocktail she used on this poor innocent man. She caused him to suffer a grotesquely inhumane death. I have read the autopsy report. She knew what she had done was murder or she would not have relinquished her medical license. She is a psychopath in my opinion and needs to be prosecuted for murder. She is a danger to normal society at the least.
I am also a board certified MD and have been helping the Bennuns with this case for the past 2 years. I am astounded by the silence from the medical community..so thank you for your comment!
All 3 doctors involved in this horrific crime should be in prison..but all 3 are still hawking their snake oil . We need to recruit more respected docs to get this case the exposure it needs .
This whole sorry saga is obviously a nightmare. This, or anything remotely like it, must not be facilitated to happen again.
This entire ordeal is nothing short of absolutely heartbreaking. I must say, this is what rears up a righteous anger within my spirit.
I read the Hippocratic Oath and taking a few words from the Greek Version, I found these interesting. ( I swear by Apollo Healer, by Asclepius, by Hygieia, by Panacea, and by all the gods and goddesses, making them my witnesses, that I will carry out, according to my ability and judgment, this oath and this indenture.) (I will use those dietary regimens which will benefit my patients according to my greatest ability and judgment, and I will do no harm or injustice to them. Neither will I administer a poison to anybody when asked to do so, nor will I suggest such a course.) Note this oath has been updated to different times and some wording has changed or been withheld. I just found it odd how the original version took oath to pagan gods/goddesses.
Nothing hides from GOD…..Ephesians 5:11 Take no part in the unfruitful works of darkness, but instead expose them.
Prayers for the Hands of our Lord and Saviour to cover y’all. GOD bless.
Where is the video that you posted late yesterday? 😕
“.These individuals – particularly Carrie Madej – should be in prison.” (my statement above) Edit: “The doctors responsible for this crime should be held accountable; Madej deserves a lengthy prison sentence. Hopefully the four doctors of the “Five Docs” take appropriate action and ditch Madej.
So sorry for your loss and trauma.
I found Israelinewslive mid 2020 during my search for TRUTH & critically thinking sometime later as well as many other alternative news sources that I continue to rely on for Truth. And I remember when Carrie was a guest on israelinewslive from Bennun’s home. So in learning of this tragic loss of Stephan & the horrific betrayal of TRUST, I too am beyond disappointed with the SILENCE by the other 4 Docs on this matter, given they have said themselves that the EvilAgenda has relied on the public’s SILENCE = Willing CONSENT. I value & BLESS Dr Ruby’s courageous support to you Jana & Steven & any other Drs willing to stand for Truth & Justice in NAME. And Oh WOE to all who continue to cling to their reputations, status or the things of this world when JESUS Comes as a Thief in the Night. JESUS reminded us in Luke 17 to REMEMBER LOT’s Wife who was warned while being rescued — DO NOT LOOK BACK. And may our Merciful HOLY LORD GOD Give you Strength in HIS PERFECT PEACE to FORGIVE & Endure with JOY looking forward to our COMING KING. It surely will Not be Long until JESUS CHRIST Takes us HOME or Suddenly Appears in the Cloud with a Trumpet Blast. Either way, the PRIZE is Heaven & Vengeance is the Lord’s.
I don’t think The Five Docs ever presented themselves as a group of Christians. Dr. P. is Jewish and Dr. Northrop sounds New Age, although she hasn’t admitted it. Dr. Merritt seems to believe in Jesus Christ but doesn’t make it a public part of her medical practice. That leaves Dr. Tenpenny who has been vocal about her Christian faith. With that said, I feel like the four of them should discuss the matter with Carrie Madej and make a determination as to whether or not they feel comfortable having a dialogue on medical topics with her. I think it would be a no brainer for them if Carrie had been convicted of the crime, but at this point it’s her word against the BenNoon family. If I was a doctor I would feel uncomfortable around her but at the same time I would want her to be convicted in a court of law before I threw her off the team. Personally I believe Steven and Jana that this woman is responsible for a horrendous death of a man that didn’t deserve to die a slow agonizing death at the hands of a so-called doctor. When she was asked to return to check on her patient she refused so that says a lot right there. No one with medical expertise could have done what she did over a period of days with plenty of time to review if what she was doing was correct and yet she did not change the protocol. . I think she is a Jewish agent infiltrator and I won’t listen to a word of what she or these other doctors have to say. They are all compromised now. As they say, one bad apple ruins the whole bunch.
Hello Carolyn
There is a forensic autopsy that proved that our father Stefan died of toxicity of hydrogen peroxide and ozone gas that Carrie Madej and her two “medical freedom” colleagues administered. There is overwhelming evidence that she came to our home and administered 21 ml of food-grade hydrogen peroxide mixed in sugar water. She nebulized our father ( only him) with the highly improper potent formula of peroxide, and he developed significant symptoms of hypoxia and burned epithelium. Hydrogen peroxide does not kill immediately; once administered in toxic amounts, it takes time to do damage. In Stefan’s case, it took about 2.5 agonizing weeks until death. She has refused to take accountability for her actions, and we have tried to speak to several freedom doctors, but only two of them cared. Dr. Tenpenny was informed fully and was very well aware of the lawsuit against Madej, yet she has decided to stop communicating with us, make a comment, and make her stand on this issue. Instead, she started promoting Carrie Madej heavily. Two weeks after we talked with her, she posted a promotion where she would have Carrie Madej on her show. We wanted to advise Dr Tenpenny to separate her name from Carrie Madej to save her credibility, albeit to no avail. At this point, we are pursuing criminal charges against Madej and the two Florida doctors; however, it is not easy.
We will come with all proofs and all evidence out to the public ourselves and disclose the entire story of what happened in every detail if authorities will not act. District Attorney ADMITTED that Carrie Madej committed at least two felonies. We will post his letter for public view shortly. The suffering and pain Carrie Madej caused to our family is indescribable and can not be explained by words alone. We want justice for Stefan Suto. Thank be to God that we – my wife and I have survived this, although she has endangered our own lives by administering such a toxic amount of hydrogen peroxide into us. Stefan could not survive it, and the details of why he could not will be explained when an entire story in all its details comes out.
Covering for Dr. Madej in light of proof offered leaves the trustworthiness of the other four doctors highly suspect. Do the right thing!
Unbelievable.
Steve and Jana, I can’t even imagine the horror you’re still living daily. To have your father taken in such a horrible manner is bad enough, almost too much to take, but the betrayal you’ve obviously felt from Madej, and now from the doctors, too. It’s great that Dr. Tenpenny did talk to you, but then for her to just shutdown has to be difficult.
I saw Steve’s first video about this and was floored. I thought surely something would come to light to somehow make it make sense, but it was obviously not to be.
I had followed Madej since she was first getting popular and doing a lot of interviews, and I thought, probably what everyone else did about her – just a nice, Christian, pretty and compassionate doctor that was also seeing through what was going on with COVID. There is absolutely no way I could have ever imagined something like this from Carrie Madej, but also now Dr. Tenpenny and Dr. Merritt. I don’t know anything about Northrup or Palevsky. I’ve seen many videos from Dr. Tenpenny and Dr. Merritt, and I just can’t imagine them being cold and uncaring. The fact that Dr. Tenpenny was still promoting Carrie Madej after all that’s happened is yet another unbelievable aspect to all of this, however. Why anyone would do that is beyond me.
I wonder if maybe they’ve all been making ridiculous amounts of money online and they’ve let it seduce them, losing track of what really matters. It obviously wouldn’t be the first time.
The only thing I can think of, which I’m sure others have considered, is that the doctors have talked to a lawyer and were advised to have no contact with Steve and Jana. However, that would still make no sense to me. There’s absolutely no way I could just ignore them, knowing what they’re going through. Especially if I could help in some way.
This entire thing just seems evil, bizarre and almost unbelievable.
I’ve thought about this often since that first video and keep going back to Madej being called after Stefan had gotten worse after she had left. How could she just refuse to come back? When I try to reconcile that, I always arrive at the same place, and it’s as though I almost can’t accept it, but it’s the ONLY logical conclusion there is. What “doctor” could turn their back on a patient in distress? Especially when it’s someone that YOU’VE just treated, and a family that you were ‘supposed’ to be close friends with!
If the doctors see this, especially Dr. Tenpenny and Dr. Merritt, please, please reach out to Steve and Jana. I’m sure even just hearing your voice would help somewhat. It would let them know that you do care. It sounds as though Steve and Jana have thorough records, so I’m guessing there’s not much that could be said to change things as far as the treatments and what’s happened, and how this is eventually resolved legally. Please, just follow your heart and your conscious and do what you know is right.
Lastly, Madej administered the peroxide at 21 ml to 500 ml of sugar water. So, I guess the Florida doctors just saw what she had administered, didn’t question it, and just did the same thing. Yeah, none of it makes sense, unless I’m not understanding everything correctly. I’m assuming the Florida doctors had also been using the same treatment protocol. If so, they would have obviously known that 21 ml was a lethal dose, especially for an older man that was already sick and weakened. Again, absolutely nothing about this makes any sense.
Steve and Jana, I’ll be praying for you guys, and I know the good Lord will provide answers and ease your pain.
This was clearly malpractice. This doctor needs to be investigated and potentially charged criminally for her actions. She should never have access to patients again.
The DA Bob Edwards and Attorney General Russell Johnson need to answer and be held accountable for this injustice. The doctors were made aware of what transpired and they still promoted Madej and treated her like a hero causing more anguish heartbreak and suffering to the surviving Ben-Nun Family. There is no justice and lawlessness is rampant. We have been fighting for justice for Stefan for well over two and a half years. Tennessee Bureau of Investigations need to investigate why this case has not been prosecuted. There is a great deal of corruption at all levels in the State of Tennessee of which some has already been exposed. Scripps Media has done a great injustice by putting forth a video and an article that is biased and has taken the word of the Attorney General at face value and did not do a proper investigation and I would like to add that their majority shareholders are Black Rock & Vanguard. They have no integrity in regards to this case. The medical examiner in Florida refused to cooperate with the forensic pathologist and someone from her office tipped off one of the doctors responsible for Stefan’s demise. An investigative reporter in Florida who was to do an article has now refused to do so because she is friends with medical examiner who has asked her not to. We have reason to believe that the Ben-Nun’s were targeted based on the findings of facts and the forensic autopsy. The Ben-Nuns promoted many of the doctors and gave them support when they were being targeted by the government and were facing the threat of losing their licenses and now when they need support all they get is crickets. These Doctors are all about recognition and profiting. They claim they are doing everything for the sake of humanity but their actions prove otherwise. Sadly even Christian ministries are taking the same path. Please share this article on social media & platforms. Call the DA of Morgan County Tennessee & Attorney General of Tennessee and demand answers.
It’s odd that everyone just blindly believes these allegations. If he was sick because of her, why wouldn’t he be brought to a local hospital in Tennessee. Why would he be transported to Florida? The obsession with allegedly obtaining a 911 call which has nothing to do with anything? We currently have doctors all over the country still pushing a covid vaccine that is causing heart problems and myocarditis etc, and Carrie Madej is the problem that needs to be sued and placed in prison!? Just stop.
What on earth are you talking about, you don’t know the story? Carrie Madej needs to be in prison. She injected deadly amounts of peroxide into three people and her formula of peroxide injured and killed a person. Then she refused to return to the patient .
Carrie Madej needs to take responsibility for her actions. Stefan died in agony and horrific death and it is proven with two forensic pathologists. Her and two Florida physicians who continued her protocol without checking on it need to go to prison for murder.